Friday, April 11, 2008

Good parenting and finding your own way home

I was listening to Talk of the Nation on NPR about journalist Lenore Skenazy who decided to leave her son at a Manhattan Bloomingdales and told him to figure out his way home with $20 and a Metrocard. Read story here. Her son made it home fine but this story got really interesting when Skenazy got accused of being a bad parent after blogging about it. She responded with what I think I was also feeling at that moment - that kids can't do much of anything on their own these days because parents are too protective. Callers who phoned in also agreed with this sentiment, especially if they grew up outside of the U.S. However, one caller who grew up in the Philippines said while culturally acceptable in the Philippines, she would never let her child take the subway alone here because other people are afraid of what might happen. That is the climate of fear has affected Americans in general where they'll act differently around an unaccompanied child.

This entire situation makes me reflect back to my own childhood. My parents and family were often too busy with work to pick me up from school sometimes. I learned at a very young age to wait up until a certain point, and then if no one showed up, I needed to get my butt home as soon as possible. SF Chinatown in the early 1980s didn't seem like a dangerous place but I knew I'd get in trouble if I didn't make my way home ASAP. On the other days, my grandfather would come and pick me up and we'd take the Muni back home. When I transferred elementary schools, I definitely had to get myself home. Though that school was only three blocks away. I don't think it was until junior high school when I was officially responsible for getting myself home at the end of the day. I'd either take Muni or just walk. Sometimes I'd walk with friends, but most of the time, I walked south on Sunset Blvd. myself.

I'm not sure what I'll do with my own kids but the coddling issue is definitely something that concerns me. The undergrads I see in school these days are at times incredibly unable to take improvise, imagine, and take care of themselves. Every assignment, every little item must be spelled out for them. The argument of course is that's different because they're working for a grade and they have every right to expect detailed instructions. But then again, whatever happened to taking the assignment to another level?

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

i get so disgusted when college age students feel a sense of entitlement. that's one of the personal benefits of working at a campus, it gives me perspective on how i would want my children to be raised. lord knows i'm a long way from that, but still..

Anonymous said...

I agree. I see it in the college applications that I read. This is the generation of kids who never went outside to play - instead, they stayed in, playing video games, texting their friends, and/or watching TV. Very sad.