I've been feeling a bit ambivalent about the Tibetan protests for independence from China. Part of my ambivalence came from not knowing enough about the history. The other part of my ambivalence came from the my suspicions about people (read- white Americans) who are critical of China on the human rights front. So many times Americans are generous with their criticisms of human rights issues in China, but they don't stop to think about the situation within the U.S. and all the human rights rights issues they criticize China for are also happening within this country. I am not condoning what China is doing and their super suppressive tactics but the U.S. needs to not run around being the international police again. I figure that the U.S. is already up to its neck in intervention-caused issues (Afghanistan, Iraq, and the list goes on and on). However, I don't want to digress too much here...
I didn't realize it but the movement for Tibetan sovereignty has had a long history. To read more go here. I've been keeping tabs on stories about the Tibetan protests of the Olympic torch that has been garnering international support. In a recent news I heard sound bytes from Chinese in the Bay Area who do not support the protest for Tibetan independence that have been occurring alongside the running of the torch. When the torch came through SF last week, it caused a huge anxiety about security and many Chinese in the Bay Area expressed frustration, saying that the Olympics are not and have never been political and the pro-Tibetan activists should not make the torch run political. Furthermore, many Bay Area Chinese think that the Olympics should be a point of pride for Chinese and pro-Tibetan activists are just taking away from China's moment in the spotlight.
I immediately reacted to the claim that the Olympics are not in anyway political. Are these people really that naive? The Olympics have always been political. As an international event that requires the cooperation and "good will" efforts of participating countries, the Olympics is the penultimate example of how politics plays out on the international scene. "Bad" countries get penalized by being super-scrutinized at the Olympics, if they are let in at all. "Good" countries get highlighted as news about their sports programs, symbolizing national strength and health, are edited into glossy news pieces. Athletes literally represent all that is good and healthy about their countries. Countries that host are brought into the global order - they have to "fix" all their "issues" and become accepted by the popular kids if they want to host.
Athletes themselves know how political the Olympics are as well. Take San Jose State University alum and international track stars Tommy Smith and John Carlos who in the late 1960s went to the Olympics in 1968 and when they were on the awards podium, held their heads in silent protest and their right arms out in Black Pride salute to bring attention the U.S. Civil Rights Movement. This silent gesture alone was seen around the world and sparked outrage that athletes would dare make a political statement at the Olympic games. They knew that the games symbolized international competition and openness but in the midst of human rights injustices that folks like MLK, Jr. and the Black Power movements were attempt to bring to light, how could a black athlete participate in the 1968 Olympics without the shadow of racism and oppression looming? Smith and Carlos demonstrated a statement that revealed the hypocrisy of the games and forced people to look hard at what the Olympics represent.
Just like Smith and Carlos, I think the pro-Tibetan activists have every right to use the Olympics games as an opportunity to bring light to their issue. After all, wasn't the initial motivation and reaction to giving China the "opportunity" to host the Olympics a means for the world to discipline their human rights violations, environmental issues, and to bring them into the international order? As defended by the president of the international Olympic committee in March:
Jacques Rogge: “It was right to award the games to China for two reasons. One is that we cannot deny one-fifth of mankind of the advantages of Olympism and the Olympic games. It’s just not fair to do that. And secondly, we believe that the games are a great catalyst for change for China itself. The games will open up China to the scrutiny of the world, thanks to the 25,000 media being present.”
I think people have poor short term memory when they criticize pro-Tibet activists. Instead, why aren't pro-China supporters listening to what Tibetans have to say instead of trying to suppress their voices?
Tuesday, April 15, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment