Wednesday, November 1, 2006

My students

I am a Teaching Assistant for a large undergraduate lecture class that focuses on Asian American History. I’ve been interacting with students in this way for some time now. In addition to TAing, I’ve taught college-level courses and have provided countless training sessions to undergraduate students. If there is one thing I am sure of, it is that I will spend the rest of my life interacting with undergraduate students in one way or another. I tried working with 6th and 7th graders while I a grad student in New York City, but I didn’t feel like I was able to connect with them as strongly as I do with college students. So this is how I ended up in grad school again; the only way I would be able to teach college students would be with a PhD.

There are a whole host of other reasons why I decided to return to school. Working in higher education, I saw patterns and things that were happening that could only be explained with conspiracy theories. As a woman of color, especially as an Asian woman, I knew I would never be able to move into the upper echelons of higher education administration without a PhD. I read somewhere that Asian women are the least like to be promoted or tenured in academe. The prospects continue to be pretty sad, but at least with a PhD many more doors will open for me.

So in order to be in grad school, I have to be a TA and take a minimum number of units to get fee remissions. It’s really a great deal if you think about it; it like work study when I was undergrad. And there is nothing like working with college students. In fact, the thing I love the most are the moments when I see a light bulb go off and they get excited about whatever it is they are thinking about. Those moments make it all worth while because I know they are engaged and interested in learning. Most likely they will take that golden morsel of knowledge and do something with it. Sometimes they tuck it away and forget that they have it only to discover it later on in life. That is acceptable to me too.

In order to be an effective TA, I’ve found that I need to adjust some of my pedagogical approaches. For example, the students I’ve had the past two year increasingly want to know specifics, details, direction for their assignments and tasks. Very few of them can deal with ambiguity well. Very few of them see lack of detail as an opportunity to be creative and expand themselves in thinking and learning. Some of the most common questions I get are: how many pages does the paper have to be? Is that single-spaced or double? How many sources do I have to have? Some of the more ridiculous questions I’ve gotten include: is discussion section mandatory? I just added the class (it’s week 4 of 10), what did I miss? Are all the books required? Is lecture attendance mandatory? Does the cover sheet and the works cited page count towards the page minimum for this paper? What’s a citation?

I love how my students try to get out of things as well…

Student: can I email the homework to you? I feel like I could have done a better job with it. Me: well why don’t you show me what you have right now?
Student: Uh… it’s on my computer
Me: well, which parts do you feel you want to improve on?
Student: Uh… the first part…
Me: What specifically about the first part?
Student: Uh… all of it?
Me: Did you do your homework?
Student: Uh…. No.

I think teachers need to spend time adjusting their pedagogy to account for the different ways now student learn. These days, some of the more traditional methods of interacting with students do not work. For example, I don’t why I have office hours sometimes. No one ever shows up. To give my students credit, many of them have class at the times I have office hours but still, there is the anxiety about seeing me in my office. I forced my students to see me at least once during the quarter and I honestly don’t know if that made any kind of difference at all. For the past three quarters, I’ve decided to give them my IM screen name and just be online whenever is convenient for me. In that medium, students have no problems asking me questions. I’ve actually gotten great feedback on it. IM is the way students engage each other so I think being there in that form, even if it is really not being physically anywhere except for in front of my computer, makes a difference for them.

The other thing I’ve noticed is that there are huge disparities with the skills that the students bring to class with them. For example, my students are writing a paper this quarter in which they have to submit a draft and then a final version to me. I had one student tell me that this paper is the longest paper he’s ever written in his life. Mind you, this paper is only 7-12 double-spaced pages. So I ask him what’s the longest paper he’s ever written? He tells me that in high school and in his other college classes right now (he’s a first year student), papers are usually around 2-3 pages. I gasped when I read that (we were in an IM conversation). I asked him where he went to high school and he told me that he went to a district public school in SF. (If I hadn’t gotten into the magnate school my parents wanted me to go to, I would have gone to this district school.) Another student asked me that he had no idea what a thesis was and could I help him? I wondered aloud if this was the first time he’s heard the word at all. He said yes. This student is also a first year student.

Not that I’m the best writer, but somehow along the way, I learned how to write well enough to get into grad school. It shocks me that some students have never learned citation method, don’t know how to structure an essay, and don’t know how to develop an argument in a paper, or even know how to cite sources in text. What are these students learning in high school? As a TA, I actually spend a lot of time teaching basic writing skills to students. I notice that most of these students who don’t know writing basics come from working-class public schools. The students who went to private school or public school in more affluent areas often have no problems putting together an essay. For them, the issue is procrastination. Many of them are over-confident so they wait until the last minute to do the work because they know they can get away with it. I see how they interact with the struggling students; they look down on them and their overconfidence becomes reinforced.

In TA training, no one ever talks about how to deal with these things. No one ever talks about fairness or how to help students who need just a little more attention. How do I teach to so many different skill sets and experiences? If I can’t figure this out as a TA now, how do I expect to be an effective professor? Will I just become disillusioned like so many other professors I know? I can only hope I won’t.