I haven't blogged about TV in awhile. I think it's probably because TV has been very ho-hum this season so far. The off-season shows I usually watch have been very so-so as well. I have been especially most disappointed by my two favorite reality shows: America's Best Dance Crew and Project Runway. Both shows seem to have suffered from similar issues, which has produced a very frustrating and dull season for viewers.
I blogged ABDC earlier in the summer but I don't think I clearly explained my disappointment. This past season was disappointing mainly because the votes didn't make much sense and the judges's choices made even less sense. My favorite crew by far was Fanny Pack, a retro group of Southern California dancers who showed innovation and serious creativity each and every week. I think many people couldn't wrap their heads around the idea of possibily having a "best" dance crew whose core moves were not based in hip hop.
The producers also seemed to put themselves in an awkward position this season because they made some odd choices in terms of finalists. First, they greenlit a crew of dance team ladies from Rutgers called Sassx7, who consistently gave the audience dance team choreography each and every week. What the heck were the producers expecting? Then they greenlit Xtreme Dance Force, a dancing rip off of every boyband that has ever been put together since the 80s. However the riskiest move was greenlighting Fanny Pak, which in the end payed off.
I am also growing weary of the format of ABDC in which the producers focus on one member's "background story." The first season it was Kaba Modern's struggle for understanding and acceptance from their Asian family. The second season it was also another Filipina female member of So Real Cru's struggle for acceptance from her "traditional" parents. What the hell is up with producers making Asian American dancers all model minority??? Then the producers kept going back to Joey, the partially deaf dancer, in Distorted X. They really should be steer clear of dramatic and sappy background stories and instead provide background info on all the dancers and the group itself in terms of being serious dancers.
America's voting was another confusing aspect of this past season of ABDC. Crews who clearly should have been eliminated (Boogie Bots, Phresh Select) kept coming back week after week. Crews who should not have been eliminated (Distorted X, Fanny Pack) met a shockingly untimely departure. Part of the difficultly was that the challenges were not well-planned. I wish the groups could pick their challenges instead of having them assigned to them. For example, I think it was the Video Star challenge and the Rock the Title challenge that were particular unchallenging for some groups while more challenging for others. Fanny Pack never got a "hip hop" icon or song to dance to and Super Cr3w never got a song that wasn't hip hop-based.
When it came down to the final three - Super Cr3w, Fanny Pack, and So Real Crew - it's no wonder that Fanny Pack got eliminated! The last three groups were all SO different that no true comparison could have been made.
This season of Project Runway has also proved to be confusing and frustrating. I have to say that the producers managed to put together the most dull and inconsistent group of designers together! Their personalities are pretty dull and their designs are not really that exciting. Last season and the season before were my favorites by far. I don't feel like there has been a standout designer this season. Furthermore, the designs that get made each week are just ok and not amazing. You can also tell the judge's disappointment as well, which cracks me up!
The challenges, like ABDC, are also really confusing. They don't seem to connect from week to week (why bother having designers design for each other using a musical genre inspiration so late in the season??? why bother designing a wedding dress and a bridesmaid dress for the final challenge??) which is problematic because consistent watchers like me don't really get a sense of how the designers' creative process evolves from week to week. I also don't get a sense of the challenges are supposed to lead up to the finale at Bryant Park. After all, are the designers being challenged on how they can handle random challenges or how they explore their creative edges/limits under pressure. Please - I need more logical connections with the challenges!
In addition, some designers have gotten to stay on a lot longer than I would like. For example, Kenley is the MOST annoying designer who is disrespectful, entitled, and self-absorbed person. Yet she manages to stay on week after week. I thought Joe and Terri got cut way too early and Suede, Keith, Blayne and Kenley got to stay way too long. Jerrell has been the most consistent and should be rewarded for his consistency; he should not have been eliminated in the final four round. The producers need to do a better job of justifying to the audience the judges' decisions to keep certain people on. I keep leaving every episode unclear about why certain designers got to stay and other did not, which dimishes my personal investment and desire to follow the show because my fave designers get eliminated without good reason.
So it's been a pretty ho-hum season for my two fave reality shows, which has been a disappointment because I don't watch a lot of reality TV. Though I don't really consider both shows reality in the sense of Survivor or Big Brother, ABDC and PR are the only ones I watch in that genre. And if I'm going to take the time to watch that kind of stuff, I wish it would be better planned.
On a different note, D's gotten me into Chuck this season. It's funny, with a lot of jokes that reference my generation (those who spent their adolescence in the 80s) and the gender politics are realy interesting. I love the fact that Huey Lewis and the News music gets worked into some of the eps and that the show also pokes fun at the drudgery of retail jobs for people who are too smart for their own good at not-so-unreal places like the Buy More.
I've also gotten to really like how Burn Notice on TNT is turning out. It's interesting and a well-written 40 minute escape. Terminator: Sarah Connor Chronicles has also been consistent as well. I am glad that the story line is beginning to move along, unlike last season when it dragged in the middle. Eureka and Stargate: Atlantis have been interesting as well, though they display the same patterns with most Sci-Fi channel shows - really dull stand-alone eps in the middle and then a mad rush of really great eps to wrap up the season.
House has been a big disappointment this season so far. The character is starting to get really intolerable and without any kind of redeeming qualities, I have hard time watching, even though the ensemble cast is terrific.
Surprisingly I have not been able to get into any of the "baby" shows that people talk so much about. I find John and Kate Plus 8 to be literally tiresome and Bring Home Baby to be depressing because every ep seems to focus on a couple that has issues or the baby itself has issues.
During the middle of the day when I usually take a lunch break from writing, I have been watching Animal Cops and Growing Up on the Animal Planet channel. I'm not sure why I've been watching both shows because whenever I watch Animal Cops, I just get pissed off at all the people who abuse animals (especially hoarders) and there is nothing I can really do about it at that moment except to give some affection to my own pets. In contrast, Growing Up focuses on how a baby animal comes into the world and survives the firs several months of life. The last two eps I've caught were about a polar bear in Quebecois Zoo and a giraffe in Safari West here in the Bay Area. The giraffe ep was amazing because I got see to see a baby giraffe being born. Everytime I watch Growing Up, I usually end up tearing up at some point because these baby animals are so freaking precious!
New shows I am undecided on include Sanctuary and Fringe. Heroes has been okay so far this season - really confusing but entertaining nonetheless. I'm anticipating the return of 24 and Lost.
Monday, October 13, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment