I don't think there is anything worse than being motion sick for me. I guess the feeling is akin to being hungover. Well, I can't be sure because I've been hungover once in my life. That time was caused by drinking too much Kahlua. But that's another story.
I am so tired. I want to go to sleep but every time I close my eyes, my nauseousness just gets worse. All I want to do is hurl. I already threw up at the theater and almost at the Macarthur BART station. I guess it's my fault since I suggested we see Cloverfield...
M, J, and I decided to go into the city and hangout tonight. There was talk about drinks, dancing, dinner, but I threw in a movie because I've been feeling tired all week. The first whole week of school usually drains me out because I'm not used to the schedule yet. Even though school technically began last week, most of the classes didn't start meeting until this week. We all decided to watch Cloverfield after some yummy dinner at Straits Cafe, one floor below the movie theaters in the Westfield complex. I was excited because I had yet to see a movie there and it was a long time since I've seen a movie with J and M. They are tons of fun to take to a movie because they join in my armchair criticisms.
Cloverfield was an obvious choice because we all wanted to see it but would never see it alone. It looked too scary and suspenseful. I was still recovering from I am Legend. I wasn't ready for that film's intenseness. Together we could be strong and make it through Cloverfield. Besides, J and I have been big fans of JJ Abrams since 2000 when we vigilantly watched Alias together.
I think J was as worried as I was about the cinematography though. We both get motion sick and the hand-held camera work was a risky thing to sit through. I was optimistic. I explained to M and J that I sat through the Blair Witch Project and didn't get motion sick. However in my optimism, I didn't think about the big difference with Cloverfield is that I didn't see BWP on the big screen (it was a rental). Oh boy...
The running sequences ended up killing me. I had to look away during those moments because my stomach began to churn in a cry for help. By the end of the film, I sat on the edge of my seat, trying to decide whether to just run or run really fast to the bathroom. As the credits appeared, M offered me some of her water. I hesitated but took it anyway. Big mistake. A small gulp of water was all it took to push me over the edge. I said in a low voice: "I think I need to go to the bathroom."
Throwing up is never fun. Standing in a stall in a public bathroom, throwing up may be the worse social faux pas. Is she drunk? Is she pregnant? Is she....? The last conclusion people make is that the film you just watched was making you throw up. Also, throwing up nothing may be even worse than throwing something up. You stand over the toilet half wishing that something would come out to help relieve the sickness, but then you also half don't want anything to come out because the sight of it would just make you want to hurl some more. Aah the taste of bile...
M and J came in to check on me as I leaned on the wall in front of me with my right hand. I stared down at the toilet. Relief eluded me. Maybe some fresh air would help. I came out and did the walk of shame towards M and J. They looked at me with sympathetic eyes. I told them that it was good that I threw up because I was feeling better now. Perhaps fresh air would make this lie a truth.
As we made our way out of the building, we reflected on the film. M immediately said she hated it. J said that her friend was going to see it tomorrow and she wanted to tell her not to go. I didn't immediately write the film off because it made me think of an article I had read some time ago...
This is when you know you're a super grad school geek because I know if I was anything else than a grad student, that is, if I was a "normal" person, I would have hated this movie. But no, I stayed open and thought critically about some of the social meanings behind the film. I recall an article I once read about how Hollywood films love to destroy New York City and what are some possible meanings to this repeated destructive spectacle. If you think about it, there have been tons of films in which NYC has been "destroyed": The Day After Tomorrow (city is frozen), Ghostbusters (city is attacked by a gigantic marshmallow man), I Am Legend (city becomes no longer viable because of a pandemic), Independence Day (aliens attack the city), Men in Black (aliens attack the city), etc. There are probably tons of other ones out there.
In this article the author, whose name escapes me at this moment, discusses how NYC becomes symbolic of US transnational financial power and all other forms of Western modernity. The destruction of the city reveals an anxiety of a loss of power and control in which "foreign" bodies attack. The threat is never from within- NYC is always getting invaded by and blown up by aliens or a mysterious disease destroys all human life on the island of Manhattan. If we believe that Hollywood filmmaking reflects the sentiments of American social consciousness, then this anxiety reveals a subconscious worrying that Americans have about being losing control and power.
So the reason why I didn't write off Cloverfield is that even though this is a film in which NYC gets destroyed, the destruction itself is interesting. In many of the other films, we know where the threat is coming from - outer space, etc. - and we often come up with names for these foreign bodies such as Godzilla (I know, this film was about Tokyo, but Tokyo can be compared to NYC in its highly urban and modern context). However in Cloverfield, the audience is never informed about the origin of the "beast." Hud, who carries the camcorder for most of the film and as a result is our "eyes and ears," momentarily ponders the origin of the threat as he scrambles up over 50 flights of stairs to a high rise about to collapse. He hypothesizes that maybe it came from the water (the Hudson?) and even though it's big we've managed to miss it all this time. The other characters don't care. They are just focused on the task at hand. And towards the end of the film, Rob, the film's hero, merely looks into the camcorder and says that the city was attacked by something unknown but shows no desire to understand what provoked the attack.
This senseless and literally "random" (which my students love to say these days) attack is frustratingly compounded with the fact that the film provides little background on the ensemble of characters. We only know the basics about them so we feel no sympathy or emotional connection with them as they run around Manhattan trying to stay alive. The only character we get a glimpse into is Hud, who also provides comic relief through disembodied voice (he is almost always behind the camera). Does he represent the audience's nervous laughter as they watched the film? The title itself is intriguing - does it signify what becomes of NYC after "the hammer?"
The spectacle of annihilation in this case reveals a different manifestation of anxiety. The unnamed foreign body, who attacks for no reason haunts us through our memories of 9/11. (Some of the scenes were really disturbing because they were so close to what I saw with my own eyes that day.) National anxiety about the lurking threat is reinforced by this film. The "little" monsters that show up in the film symbolize the everyday and localized threats that can sneak up on us in the dark (lest we are vigilant). The detached state of the characters reflect the current state of disorientation - we don't really know why we are or why we should be afraid, we just need to be afraid. Even love is not enough to save us at the end of the day because we are destroyed by ourselves in our efforts to contain the threat. We walk away from the film disconnected with the characters and we are disoriented by what has transpired in the film. (The audience left almost immediately without applause or response, which to me is a very bad sign.) This film is not escapist because it provides no alternative imagination with hope underlying the plot. We are only encouraged to imagine otherwise through the title, and that is reaching at best.
I think Cloverfield may be JJ Abram's greatest subversive achievement. I was telling J and M that he's probably sitting in his penthouse in NYC laughing all the way to his bank. I bet Cloverfield will be the top grossing film this weekend because we've all bought into the mystery and hype. JJ Abrams probably told the Paramount execs that he could slap together a film, Blair Witch-style, produce very little character development and provide illogical reasons for a monster to attack America's favorite city and get Americans to come out to see the film. He's laughing at home because he's figured out the new Hollywood formula - a dash of romance, heavy handed spectacle, suspense and masked gore, a big mysterious monster, the will to survive, and wah-lah!
The question is, how will Americans respond? I can't wait to see the Yahoo user reviews after this weekend... Oh, and I've never been able to find a cure for my motion sickness until now. I'm feeling great after writing this post. Perhaps that's what I need to do in the future. Off to bed!
Saturday, January 19, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
after watching the film, i was a bit intrigued & i decided to follow up on some of the reviews. it actually got some good reviews. the fact that the origin of monster was never identified was favorable to some critics and how we never really get to see the monster in its complete form close up adds to the mystery. everything about this film was made to be mysterious. maybe it's not meant to be entertaining, but rather to create dialogue about movie-making and the "blockbuster" movie genre. he only made the movie for about 30mil too.
Post a Comment