Friday, January 23, 2009

TV advertising and neocon ideology

On Thursday's edition of All Things Considered on NPR, there was an interesting piece on how marketing folks are taking advantage of the recession in recent advertising campaigns. Martin Kaste explains how recent television commercials are taking up the idea of thrift and cutting back in this recession economy in order to sell. He provides several examples of how companies are beginning to convince customers that it's okay to want to save, so if you're going to spend your hard-earned money, spend it with (fill in the blank company)!

The discourse on the recession in general is quite interesting as well. Perhaps this is where advertisers and marketing execs are picking up on the tone of financial crisis and harnessing it to stoke the flames of American fear. The average American who watches television these days is not only bombarded with news stories (on local as well as Headline News) about the deepening recession, but also gets and extra poke from ads that encourage thrift and worry.

Politicians are key to framing this rich discourse as well. The recession, after all, has been caused by failing American banking and auto industries that ripple out to the housing crisis and the average 50,000 jobs being cut everyday (according to the San Jose Mercury News). They use words such as "reigning in" and "disciplining" corporations and industries who are asking for bailout money. Republicans and moderate democrats scoff at industries that have "not kept up with the rest of the world" or who have not spent their money wisely.

When did we become a nation of fat, overspending, self-indulgent, and wasteful Americans?

If we connect what's being said on Capitol Hill and what we're seeing in TV ads, we can begin to recognize that resurgence of vocabulary that is familiar to my generation. Bootstraps capitalism and welfare blame seem to haunt the current discourse on the importance of personal thrift and the need for more "transparency." That is, during the Reagan era, the homeless and poor were blamed for their situation; they were homeless and poor because they were lazy and didn't work hard. The only way for them to lift themselves out of poverty was to pull themselves up by their own bootstrap and take personal responsibility for their situation. The result was the dismantling of government programs that funded community organizations that helped the poor and homeless. Cutting out "handouts" (as Republicans referred to it) would teach these lazy people to work harder.

Thus current ads not only echo cries for neoconservativism based on "personal responsibility," but also blame those who have been irresponsible (people who took ridiculous loans they didn't understand). We have returned once again to the emphasis on personal responsibility. And again, we are not talking about the real causes for our recession - the failure of American capitalism.

No comments: