Tuesday, February 19, 2008

The "Asian" vote

Apparently someone cares...

Asians emerge as swing voters in White House race

by P. Parameswaran /Tue Feb 19, 10:37 PM ET
http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20080220/wl_asia_afp/usvoteasia


WASHINGTON (AFP) - Asians have become a critical swing voter bloc in the US presidential election race, with rival parties courting them ahead of another intense White House contest.

"If this is a close election, then the ways in which the Asian-American vote swings could have a very decisive impact," said Don Nakanishi, director of the Asian-American studies center at the University of California, Los Angeles.

The top five states where Asian-Americans reside are California, New York, Texas, Hawaii and New Jersey, and all, with the exception of Hawaii, are "very, very significant" in the presidential elections because of the high number of electoral votes each carries, Nakanishi said.

Despite their significance, the voting power of Asian-Americans has been much less scrutinized than that of African-Americans and Hispanics, the country's other leading minority groups, said The Hill, a newspaper that covers Congress.

Studies have shown that Asians tend to vote mostly for the Democratic party, in which Senators Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama are in a neck-and-neck battle to be party flagbearer for the presidential race.

A rapidly growing group, there are now 14 million Asian-Americans in the United States, making up five percent of the total population. Their number is expected to nearly triple in 2050 to 41 million, government figures show.

Some seven million Asian-Americans are eligible to vote, and close to 3.5 million have registered to vote in the presidential election.

The power of the Asian-American vote is overlooked, said Democratic lawmaker Mike Honda, chairman of the Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus. "It is time that due attention is paid to this rapidly growing and politically relevant community," he said. Honda led several lawmakers in lobbying for more US media coverage of the Asia-Pacific vote in the elections, saying they were "deeply concerned" about what they saw as lack of press coverage. This, they pointed out, "unfairly suppresses a growing and significant political constituency."

In the California Democratic nomination battle earlier this month, about 75 percent of Asian voters cast their ballots for Clinton compared to 23 percent for Obama, according to reports.

That's almost as high as the percentage of the black vote of 78 percent that went for Obama. But in the run-up to the fight, Obama had narrowed Clinton's lead to such an extent that the Asian vote suddenly became pivotal, the reports said.

With the solid backing from Asians, Clinton carried 54 percent of the Democratic electorate in California, leading Obama by 14 percent in the state and significantly increasing her electoral votes. The Asian-American community is also poised to play significant roles in contests in Wisconsin, Hawaii, Ohio, Texas, Pennsylvania, and North Carolina.

As the race intensifies, campaigners for Clinton and Obama as well as those for the presumptive Republican presidential candidate Senator John McCain are casting their eyes on Asian-American voters.

McCain is quite popular among Asian-Americans attracted by his immigration reforms and bipartisanship. Clinton has strong ties with Indian-Americans, cultivated way back when her husband Bill Clinton was president. She had once joked at a fundraising event that she was "delighted to be the senator from Punjab." But she was attacked by the Obama campaign, which cited the Punjab joke and her ties to companies which have outsourced US jobs to India.

Following criticism from some Indian-American lobby groups, the Obama campaign expressed regret and asserted that he was a "longtime friend" of the Indian-American community. Obama's ties to the Asian-American community are also deep. He had once lived in Indonesia and Hawaii and his half-sister is half Indonesian.

--

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Hanging with Gramps

One of the things I love most about my gramps is what I call his "stealth" humor....

I had to drop my car off in the City the other day so I decided to have dinner with my parents and grandparents. My gramps, or goong goong as I say in Cantonese, was in a good mood the other night. My mom thinks it was because the weather was good (gramps claims his arthritis acts up when it's gloomy, which is often in the City). After dinner we watched the Phoenix Suns play the Golden State Warriors. Goong goong had been a long time fan of Michael Jordan and the Chicago Bulls, back in their heyday in the 1980s, but in the 1990s he followed the Lakers. Kobe and Shaq were amongst his favorite players in the past decade but with the disintegration of the Lakers and the departure and return of Phil Jackson, goong goong followed players now more than anything else.

The recent trade of Shaq to the Phoenix Suns left him with mixed emotions. Last year, goong goong followed Shaq's time with the Miami Heat and became enamored with the Suns because of Steve Nash's performance. As we watched the exciting, fast-paced game, he turned to me and asked if I knew that Shaq had been traded. I nodded and responded with great skepticism about his addition. He agreed - too old, too slow, he said, not right for this fast team. We continued to watch the game. He then said, what is Shaq supposed to help with? My mom sat down on the couch next to us and joined in the conversation by nodding in agreement to goong goong's observation. My mom then said that he might be a good at blocking (Jaw) people, to which my grandfather created a pun with my mom's words. Goong goong then added "jaw jee," which turned Shaq, a great blocker, into an obstacle to and standing in the way of his Suns teammates. We all cracked up at his clever pun.

We sat in silence until the next commercial break. Goong goong then turned to me and asked if I heard about Hillary's losses in the Potomac primaries. He asked who I voted for: Hee-lah-lee or the hok gwai. I laughed and said the hok gwai. He laughed at me and said that a lot of young people like me were voting for him now. He then added that a lot of rich white people who voted for hee-lah-lee's husband were now supporting Oh-bam-ah as well. I asked him who he liked. He said Hee-lah-lee, of course. I asked why and he explained that her husband was a good man and did a lot to make the economy strong, look at us now...

I asked him if he would like to vote this election, especially since he was now a citizen. He and my grandma (paw paw) had taken the citizenship examination a couple of years ago but never registered to vote because they didn't speak or write English. It never occurred to me to see if they were interested in voting until that evening. He thought about it for a bit and said, "I'd like to but what would an old person like me who doesn't speak English contribute?" I let him think about it a bit more. Halftime was approaching and the game was tied.

"Aiya" he said as the Suns turned over the ball. He then said to me, what do I need to do? Can I get one of those mail-in ballots? My mom smiled and said of course, that's what your smart granddaughter does, and I need to do that too! He nodded and said "aiyah" again as the Suns turned over the ball again. Goong goong then turned to me and said, may be a hok gwai can make a difference because all bok gwai know how to do is screw things up! We cracked up as the game went into halftime.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Ridiculousness

....or as my friend T likes to refer to it - utter ridiculousness...

I went on a run with Obi this morning and for some reason started thinking about all the things that undergrads do that make me chuckle. Here they are in no particular order:

1. Ugg boots appropriately worn in the rain and cold are still UGGly. They make people look like they have Transformers feet. I hear people say that they're comfortable and whatnot but they just don't make anything look even remotely "cute." Paris Hilton was never cute when she first wore them (actually I've never considered her "cute" at all so I guess that example wasn't a good one).

2. Biking with heels on. I saw the funniest thing yesterday. An Asian student was wearing patent leather pumps with maybe 2 inch heels and she was trying to retract the kickstand and she couldn't do it because she was telling her friend (see #3) that she didn't want to ruin her shoes.

3. Black tights worn inside short, cuffed shorts. I never thought I would see the day that this trend would return. I did it in the early 80s so I understand the uncomfortable feeling of wearing tights under short shorts. Standing next to Asian student (see #2) was another Asian student who was wearing black tights under short shorts. She was at least wearing some sensible flat boots, but then again... they had little tassels hanging off the zipper. I still can't decide if the boots are cute though.

4. Students who show up to an 80 minute lecture to do Sudoku or play with their cell phone. I say, why bother showing up at all? It's not as if they have enough brain bandwidth to soak anything up through osmosis. I have a student who shows up to lecture all the time and all he does is play with his iPhone. He doesn't even bother taking out a notebook or a piece of paper to make it look like he cares. Then there are two student who show up and at the start of lecture, they race to see who can finish the daily Sudoku. (Once they figured out I was one of the TAs, they immediately moved across the room.) Why don't they just stay at home or at least go out into the sunshine to waste time??

5. Why is it that when it’s cold and freezing that I always see a guy wearing shorts? And why is the guy always white??

6. Flipflops in the rain. This is particularly gross in Davis because much of campus is unpaved. What's worse are students who wear ugly flipflops, like the generic ones that you wear when you need to run out to get the mail or the paper.

7. Talking on the cell phone (without a hands free set) and biking at the same time. I personally think this practice should be banned because I've seen so many people (including myself) almost get hit by someone yapping away and screwing up the bike circle turn. And why the hell do they always look pissed off at you when you stop to get out their way when they're biking all crazy???

8. Listening to an iPod (or anything other kind of MP3 device) and biking at the same time. Again, another practice I think should be banned for really basic safety reasons. How the hell are you supposed to hear anything with music blasting in your ears? My fave is when students are biking through downtown Davis. They're not stopping for traffic at the stop signs and they're always listening to their iPod! They end up screwing up the four-way stops as well as other people biking and driving around them who actually obey the traffic laws.

9. Taking pictures of the powerpoint lecture slides with a cell phone instead of taking notes. This isn't a recent one, but it's worth throwing onto this list because of the utter ridiculousness (thanks again to T for coining this most appropriate phrase) of it. This happened last year in a class I was TAing. The prof noticed some flashes coming from the back row (of a 250 person class) and stopped her lecture to ask what was going on. After some confusion, the student admitted that she was taking pictures on her cell phone of the powerpoint notes because the prof refused to post her slides online or give out copies. Um... whatever happened to note-taking?

10. Feeding the permit machine with one dollar bills and change while ten other cars are waiting in line. (Maybe this annoys me more than makes me chuckle.) So why is it that every time there is a car in front of me buying a $6 day permit at the parking structure that the person is trying to feed the machine with crinkled bills and coins??? Then the person always, always, always looks back at me like, sorry- I don't know why this machine isn't taking my money! Why don't people just use their credit cards??? I see students use their credit cards for a bag of chips in the coffee house all the time. This is so ironic because credit/ATM purchases take TWICE as long to process as cash transactions. So wwwwhhhhhyyyyyyy??????

Ok, I think I'm done venting...

Friday, February 8, 2008

Thoughts on a Super Tuesday

What can me more exciting than an election year? I must confess... I am a political junkie. Perhaps this unusual (the only reason why I say unusual is that I have few friend who are as into politics as I am) interest of mine comes from the fact that one childhood dream of mine was to get elected into office somewhere. I think I imagined myself a senator at one point.

I have been following the primaries and caucuses as closely as possible but things keep getting in the way! Being in class and having to fulfill grad student duties prevents me from being in front of the computer, watching CNN all day, and listening to NPR all at once (damn responsibilities). If not for those "other" things, I think I'd just turn into a recluse and read everything about the elections. I don't know why I find this stuff so fascinating.

This election, I have been really torn about the dems. The Clinton and Obama is crazy and to be honest, I'm not sure what the hell is going to happen. It's freaking exciting not to know. And it's scary to think about the possibility of McCain becoming president. As fascinated as I am about the possibility of having the first woman or Black man be president, I think the more interesting stuff is happening over at the repub camp. Now that Romney has dropped out, the repubs are clearly going to select McCain. The interesting is the divide amongst conservatives regarding McCain. Conservative talk show hosts are accusing McCain of not being conservative enough. How crazy is that? Conservatives up in arms about who is more authentically conservative! I never thought I'd see the day...

So in an attempt to get all my other friends into my political frenzy, I installed a couple of applications on my facebook page that I thought would be interesting to friends. I absolutely love the insta-quiz that shows which presidential candidate I am most like. Here are the shocking results:

Biden vs you 75% similar
Brownback vs you 22% similar
Clinton vs you 70% similar
Cox vs you 25% similar
Dodd vs you 70% similar
Edwards vs you 70% similar
Giuliani vs you 31% similar
Gravel vs you 100% similar
Huckabee vs you 15% similar
Hunter vs you 0% similar
Kucinich vs you 96% similar
McCain vs you 34% similar
Obama vs you 76% similar
Paul vs you 52% similar
Richardson vs you 73% similar
Romney vs you 7% similar
Tancredo vs you 8% similar
Thompson vs you 18% similar

I've bolded my top 2 matches and top 2 non-matches. I was so surprised at how this turned out. My friend C also matched Mike Gravel at 100% so she looked him up. My other friend T also matched Gravel 100%. So it's been this hilarious joke between us that we're going to vote for Gravel just because he matches all of us on the issues we feel are important.

After a little bit of reflecting on this continuous joke, I actually started feeling kind of sad. I realized that someone like Gravel would never have a chance because he's seen as too extreme. So in order to get elected or even get heard in order to try to get real change happening, one has to compromise values and beliefs. Though this is something that I know obviously happens, I wonder, ethically, what gets lost along the way. I suppose it would be unrealistic to have someone as liberal as he is in the office of the President because he would never be able to "unite the nation" (which is everyone's biggest concern with the remaining candidates).

The heartening thing about this year has been the rejuvenated interest in presidential politics. When I went to drop off my mail-in ballot (don't ask me why I waited until the last minute to get it in), the line was crazy at my polling place! And people were patiently standing in line to vote! It was such a beautiful thing. I really think that people take for granted the ability to vote. Those who don't vote are throwing away the easiest way to tell politicians, the pundits, the pollsters, the media, and your neighbors what you believe. And people forget about other died for the right to vote, that people in other countries are still struggling for democracy and the basic right to vote, and that voting is a hard-won privilege and responsibility of being an American.

Ok, so off my soapbox...

Monday, February 4, 2008

Reenergizement

I just got back from spending the weekend with about 60 Asian American college students this weekend. The UCD Asian Pacific Islander Leadership Retreat (APILR) was an absolutely amazing experience for me on so many levels. Initially I was really nervous about going because I went as twice an undergrad and I remember feeling extreme emotion and joy. Coming back as a grad student facilitator and workshop presenter was not bad at all. I think there is a mix of wanting the students to like, balancing my "research" (I was there to also observe and get to know them), while really trying to make an impact on students at an individual level. I think there is also a little part of me that was worried that the students would perceive me as "old" and distance themselves from me. That fear was definitely not the case.

The weekend is built on the premise that Asian American students need a space to come together to talk about issues specific to their interests and needs. Culturally, the topics addressed at the retreat were more relevant to their home lives and community engagements. I was very impressed with the conscious effort by the student planners to create many different kinds of opportunities for students to engage in because the group was definitely diverse. Some students were calling for anarchy and revolution, some students wanted to work on campus issues, while others just wanted to help out and get connected with other folks.

Personally, the retreat, as tiring as it was, worked to re-energize me. I don't know if trying to grad school has made me internalize some of the crappy things academics think about students, but I saw passionate, active, and energetic students who were not politically apathetic, ignorant of the issues, or dispassionate about wanting to get involved. Students were eloquent, some knew a lot of community issues, and many spoke with an unwavering tone about struggling for equality. I was completely inspired and reminded of what I was doing with my life.

The first workshop session made clear the slight ivory tower attitude I had taken on in the past several years. The main focus was on the underlying meaning or the unspoken words during conversations between family members. I was so surprised at myself in particular because some things that I thought were resolved in my life came to the surface as unresolved issues.

Under pressure in the activity, I blurted out something that highlighted my insecurities about having a "non-traditional" career. I think the other participants were surprised as well. As one student shared with me afterwards, she thought that I carried myself with a lot of confidence and that I was surprised I expressed some anxiety about not making my family proud of what I do.

I was supposed to go to law school and be a lawyer after all. So far, I've been the only one in my family to break off and do something "nontraditional." And as the first born in the US, the eldest in my generation, the only child, and just basically always being the oldest, the burden of filial piety and honoring my family are feelings that I have always foregrounded in my decisions about life. I think deciding not to got to law has been one of the major turning points in my life because of the impact it has had on my career. Deciding to become an academic has not been an easy choice, especially since grad school itself is so unrewarding and demeaning at times. I often wonder why I put myself through this torture.

However, that session and this retreat in general helped me reflect on what the hell has been going on in my life the past couple years and where I want it to go in the near future. I want to work with Asian American college students dammit. That is what gets me out of bed in the morning and what sustains me when stupid , seemingly unexplainable and unfair things happen in life. I think I started getting tired and began to complain about the things that I hear faculty complaining about: oh students don't care - all they want is to get a good grade no matter what cost; this generation is not respectful of teachers and education - they'd rather talk on their cell phone or listen to their ipod; students are too career driven and entrepreneurial - they don't care about the the humanities and learning about critical thinking. I've repeated all these highly pessimistic things to other people at some point in these past two years. I completely regret being complicit in condoning the stereotype.

On another note, the students were obsessed with this card game called Mao. I am still trying to figure out what the heck is going on with the game because I don't know how to play it yet. The fascinating part is that figuring out the rules is the main objective. When you disobey rules, you are punished in various ways. It's an absolutely outrageous game and I think I need to work this into my interviews with students. After all, what are Asian American students fascinated by a game in which the objective is to figure out the rules? I love the irony.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Low geek self-esteem

I pride myself on being a geek (or a nerd in some instances). And I think my geek power is pretty strong most of the time. Reflecting on my adolescence, I think most of my friends were pretty brainy in some way. Even if they were slackers who cut school most of the time, they were smart about how they did it and what they did with their time. One of my favorite TV shows is still Jeopardy. My family used to bug me about auditioning for it and I even had dreams of going on College Students week on Jeopardy. Yeah, I am pretty full of my geek self.

To me, being smart isn't just about knowing random facts though. Smartness has a feeling of "book" intelligence and "street" intelligence. Knowing how to utilize certain types of smarts is crucial to surviving in this awful world. I am not saying that have achieved this perfect balance between the book and the street. I just like the challenge of being thrown into situations where both my book and street intelligence gets called upon. However, don't get me wrong- sometimes knowing the words to that obscure Police song goes a long way when I'm playing a trivia board game.

Lately I've been feeling like I am slipping. On several occasions, I have been out-geeked in the most surprising ways. The latest surprise has been my friend D, who knows everything about 80s pop music. Since I wrote my MA thesis on hip hop music of the 1980s and 1990s and since I have been a radio whore for most of my life, I have taken every Name That Tune challenge with confidence. D, however, blows me away because he can name every 80s pop song he hears, sing along with the right words, and name the samples mixed in the track. It takes me a little longer but I can eventually come up with the right answer. But D is on point all the time. This is impressive stuff.

C, another friend, has insane knowledge about all things literary. She is an English PhD student of course, so perhaps she has an excuse. I've played Trivial Pursuit with her before and she leaves me in the dust in the Arts and Literature category. She has all this weird knowledge about obscure historical facts as well. Her blog is wickedly funny and she's a great writer. And she lets me crash on her couch Monday nights so I guess I can't hate on her.

The feeling of supreme geekiness also appears in my academic endeavors. I guess you can't be a PhD student without feeling smart. Yet it is only recently that I have been able to feel like I'm smart in the academic sense. What can account for this?

For the past 2 years I think I have been struggling to find my voice and be able to articulate my ideas clearly. I constantly felt like I was always behind my classmates and struggling to understand the readings in my classes. I think I only took one or two classes where I felt confident about the material and able to contribute in an articulate way. I think the other part of it is also the realization that my academic work is truly unique - that is, no one else is working on what I am working on in the slightest way. As a result, I can only talk to certain people about certain aspects of my interests, but never in an entirety.

My friends are kind of like that too. I wonder if this is the case of most people. What does it mean that I have groups of friends who I would never bring together with others? Clashing ideas and interests would definitely make for a suck-ass party. Who wants that? I guess I have different groups of friends for the same reason that I have different people I must turn to in my academic world.

I guess all this doubt has made me wonder what my academic career is going to be like once I finally get that piece of paper framed and up on the wall of diplomas in my office. (I put up my diplomas and D's diplomas but left one big space for what I consider is my "last diploma.") After all, I am no-traditional PhD student. I am not at a big name school or program. I don't have big name advisers or faculty on my committee. I am not funded at all. I'm fast-tracking by trying to finish in 4 years. I haven't built up my CV with publications, book reviews, research projects, and fellowships. I can't do a national search when I come onto the job market. I have an almost unrecognizable degree and I have to constantly explain my research to give context to why I'm doing what I'm doing where I'm doing it.

To make matters worse, I personally have not bought into the Ivory Tower like most "successful" graduate students have. I believe there are other possibilities out there for me. I used to say that I was interested in going into administrative work in higher education. A Dean's position or perhaps a Provost position perhaps. I'm not so sure about things these days. Then there is that crazy idea to open a doggie store with K and O. Or maybe doing consulting work as a diversity "specialist"? So I guess these options make the glass half-full?

Looking at what I wrote makes me ask myself: What the hell am I doing????

Self-doubt always seems to creep in when I least expect it. On bad days, I feel like I'm going to be forced to be a lecturer, driving all over the Bay Area when I'm done. Not that I wouldn't like to be a lecturer, but lecturers are hired from semester to semester and quarter to quarter, without any kind of long-term stability. Or worse- I'll end up unable to find any kind of academic job at all. That would be academic suicide. If I step away right after my PhD, I'm not sure I'll be able to recover. But then again, how much of this can I really control? I won't have any idea what the "market" will be like when I'm done with my PhD, so what's the point in worrying? Logic doesn't seem to work very well when I have low geek self-esteem.

I guess in the meantime, all I can do is just focus on the baby steps. None of this will matter if I don't pass my exams in May. I can definitely kiss my academic career goodbye if that happens. I know I have put a lot of pressure on myself to accomplish what I set out to do, but the weight of it all gives me a backache sometimes.

On a happier note, I dropped off my application for the a fellowship this morning and I dropped off my IRB forms for signatures. Two more steps closer...

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Cloverfield and other forms of nauseousness

I don't think there is anything worse than being motion sick for me. I guess the feeling is akin to being hungover. Well, I can't be sure because I've been hungover once in my life. That time was caused by drinking too much Kahlua. But that's another story.

I am so tired. I want to go to sleep but every time I close my eyes, my nauseousness just gets worse. All I want to do is hurl. I already threw up at the theater and almost at the Macarthur BART station. I guess it's my fault since I suggested we see Cloverfield...

M, J, and I decided to go into the city and hangout tonight. There was talk about drinks, dancing, dinner, but I threw in a movie because I've been feeling tired all week. The first whole week of school usually drains me out because I'm not used to the schedule yet. Even though school technically began last week, most of the classes didn't start meeting until this week. We all decided to watch Cloverfield after some yummy dinner at Straits Cafe, one floor below the movie theaters in the Westfield complex. I was excited because I had yet to see a movie there and it was a long time since I've seen a movie with J and M. They are tons of fun to take to a movie because they join in my armchair criticisms.

Cloverfield was an obvious choice because we all wanted to see it but would never see it alone. It looked too scary and suspenseful. I was still recovering from I am Legend. I wasn't ready for that film's intenseness. Together we could be strong and make it through Cloverfield. Besides, J and I have been big fans of JJ Abrams since 2000 when we vigilantly watched Alias together.

I think J was as worried as I was about the cinematography though. We both get motion sick and the hand-held camera work was a risky thing to sit through. I was optimistic. I explained to M and J that I sat through the Blair Witch Project and didn't get motion sick. However in my optimism, I didn't think about the big difference with Cloverfield is that I didn't see BWP on the big screen (it was a rental). Oh boy...

The running sequences ended up killing me. I had to look away during those moments because my stomach began to churn in a cry for help. By the end of the film, I sat on the edge of my seat, trying to decide whether to just run or run really fast to the bathroom. As the credits appeared, M offered me some of her water. I hesitated but took it anyway. Big mistake. A small gulp of water was all it took to push me over the edge. I said in a low voice: "I think I need to go to the bathroom."

Throwing up is never fun. Standing in a stall in a public bathroom, throwing up may be the worse social faux pas. Is she drunk? Is she pregnant? Is she....? The last conclusion people make is that the film you just watched was making you throw up. Also, throwing up nothing may be even worse than throwing something up. You stand over the toilet half wishing that something would come out to help relieve the sickness, but then you also half don't want anything to come out because the sight of it would just make you want to hurl some more. Aah the taste of bile...

M and J came in to check on me as I leaned on the wall in front of me with my right hand. I stared down at the toilet. Relief eluded me. Maybe some fresh air would help. I came out and did the walk of shame towards M and J. They looked at me with sympathetic eyes. I told them that it was good that I threw up because I was feeling better now. Perhaps fresh air would make this lie a truth.

As we made our way out of the building, we reflected on the film. M immediately said she hated it. J said that her friend was going to see it tomorrow and she wanted to tell her not to go. I didn't immediately write the film off because it made me think of an article I had read some time ago...

This is when you know you're a super grad school geek because I know if I was anything else than a grad student, that is, if I was a "normal" person, I would have hated this movie. But no, I stayed open and thought critically about some of the social meanings behind the film. I recall an article I once read about how Hollywood films love to destroy New York City and what are some possible meanings to this repeated destructive spectacle. If you think about it, there have been tons of films in which NYC has been "destroyed": The Day After Tomorrow (city is frozen), Ghostbusters (city is attacked by a gigantic marshmallow man), I Am Legend (city becomes no longer viable because of a pandemic), Independence Day (aliens attack the city), Men in Black (aliens attack the city), etc. There are probably tons of other ones out there.

In this article the author, whose name escapes me at this moment, discusses how NYC becomes symbolic of US transnational financial power and all other forms of Western modernity. The destruction of the city reveals an anxiety of a loss of power and control in which "foreign" bodies attack. The threat is never from within- NYC is always getting invaded by and blown up by aliens or a mysterious disease destroys all human life on the island of Manhattan. If we believe that Hollywood filmmaking reflects the sentiments of American social consciousness, then this anxiety reveals a subconscious worrying that Americans have about being losing control and power.

So the reason why I didn't write off Cloverfield is that even though this is a film in which NYC gets destroyed, the destruction itself is interesting. In many of the other films, we know where the threat is coming from - outer space, etc. - and we often come up with names for these foreign bodies such as Godzilla (I know, this film was about Tokyo, but Tokyo can be compared to NYC in its highly urban and modern context). However in Cloverfield, the audience is never informed about the origin of the "beast." Hud, who carries the camcorder for most of the film and as a result is our "eyes and ears," momentarily ponders the origin of the threat as he scrambles up over 50 flights of stairs to a high rise about to collapse. He hypothesizes that maybe it came from the water (the Hudson?) and even though it's big we've managed to miss it all this time. The other characters don't care. They are just focused on the task at hand. And towards the end of the film, Rob, the film's hero, merely looks into the camcorder and says that the city was attacked by something unknown but shows no desire to understand what provoked the attack.

This senseless and literally "random" (which my students love to say these days) attack is frustratingly compounded with the fact that the film provides little background on the ensemble of characters. We only know the basics about them so we feel no sympathy or emotional connection with them as they run around Manhattan trying to stay alive. The only character we get a glimpse into is Hud, who also provides comic relief through disembodied voice (he is almost always behind the camera). Does he represent the audience's nervous laughter as they watched the film? The title itself is intriguing - does it signify what becomes of NYC after "the hammer?"

The spectacle of annihilation in this case reveals a different manifestation of anxiety. The unnamed foreign body, who attacks for no reason haunts us through our memories of 9/11. (Some of the scenes were really disturbing because they were so close to what I saw with my own eyes that day.) National anxiety about the lurking threat is reinforced by this film. The "little" monsters that show up in the film symbolize the everyday and localized threats that can sneak up on us in the dark (lest we are vigilant). The detached state of the characters reflect the current state of disorientation - we don't really know why we are or why we should be afraid, we just need to be afraid. Even love is not enough to save us at the end of the day because we are destroyed by ourselves in our efforts to contain the threat. We walk away from the film disconnected with the characters and we are disoriented by what has transpired in the film. (The audience left almost immediately without applause or response, which to me is a very bad sign.) This film is not escapist because it provides no alternative imagination with hope underlying the plot. We are only encouraged to imagine otherwise through the title, and that is reaching at best.

I think Cloverfield may be JJ Abram's greatest subversive achievement. I was telling J and M that he's probably sitting in his penthouse in NYC laughing all the way to his bank. I bet Cloverfield will be the top grossing film this weekend because we've all bought into the mystery and hype. JJ Abrams probably told the Paramount execs that he could slap together a film, Blair Witch-style, produce very little character development and provide illogical reasons for a monster to attack America's favorite city and get Americans to come out to see the film. He's laughing at home because he's figured out the new Hollywood formula - a dash of romance, heavy handed spectacle, suspense and masked gore, a big mysterious monster, the will to survive, and wah-lah!

The question is, how will Americans respond? I can't wait to see the Yahoo user reviews after this weekend... Oh, and I've never been able to find a cure for my motion sickness until now. I'm feeling great after writing this post. Perhaps that's what I need to do in the future. Off to bed!